Manifestation vs. Goal Setting: What Actually Works for the Year Ahead  

Written By Anna Grutzner

At this early stage of the year, many people are setting resolutions, intentions and manifestations for the year ahead. Or maybe you call it goal setting - using a method like SMART to break it all down into tangible steps. It can sound like two competing camps: one focused on mindset and energy, the other on plans and spreadsheets. In reality, the most effective approach is not choosing one or the other, but understanding how they work together in the brain and behaviour.

That’s why Gracie and I spent new years day together creating vision boards for the year ahead, while also setting out clear, tangible goals with metrics for our personal and working lives (with a quarterly Soluna check-in!). So why do both matter?

At a high level, manifestation helps shape what you notice and pay attention to, while goal setting and planning determine what you consistently do over time. Manifestation acts like a mental filter for decision making; goal setting is the commitment to specific actions over weeks, months and quarters, broken down into achievable steps.



How manifestation links to your brain’s “filter”

A useful way to understand manifestation is through the lens of selective attention and a brain system often called the reticular activating system (RAS). The RAS is involved in regulating wakefulness and attention; one of its practical roles is filtering the huge amount of sensory information hitting your nervous system so that only some of it reaches conscious awareness.

It prioritises information that seems important to you: your name in a noisy room, topics you care about, things that are emotionally charged, or cues related to your current goals and concerns. When you repeatedly focus on a value, goal, or desired outcome - as many manifestation practices encourage - you are effectively training your attentional system to tag related information as “relevant”.

That means:

- You are more likely to notice opportunities that fit your intentions (a networking event, a new role, a chance to learn a relevant skill).

- You are quicker to detect patterns and feedback related to what you care about (for example, which habits are helping or hurting your goal).

In this way, manifestation is less about magically attracting outcomes and more about priming your perception and attention so you navigate the world differently. Your decisions change when you consistently see and prioritise different information.


Intentions, goals and why “just wanting it” is not enough

Psychology makes an important distinction between intentions and plans. A goal intention is a statement like “I intend to get fitter this year” or “I want to grow my business revenue”. It is helpful, but does not reliably change behaviour.

A large body of research shows that adding implementation intentions makes a big difference. These are if-then plans that specify when, where and how you will act, such as: “If it is 7am on weekdays, then I will walk briskly for 20 minutes” or “If I finish my project early, then I will spend 30 minutes on outbound sales”. Across dozens of experiments, people who formed implementation intentions achieved their goals significantly more often than those with only vague intentions.

In one study, participants who added if–then plans to their goals completed demanding tasks and personal projects at much higher rates than those who simply said they intended to do them. The key insight: clarity about what you will do in specific situations helps your brain automate the desired response when those situations arise. This is where manifestation and planning intersect: your intentions tell the brain what to treat as important; your plans tell it what to do when importance shows up in real life.


SMART goals and longer timeframes

Over a month, quarter, or year, you need more than good intentions; you need a structure for tracking progress and adjusting course. This is where goal-setting frameworks like SMART come in. SMART goals are typically defined as specific, measurable, achievable, realistic/relevant and time-bound.

The idea is to move from “I want to be healthier” to something like: “I will complete 150 minutes of moderate exercise per week by doing 30 minutes of brisk walking five days a week, tracked on my calendar, for the next 12 weeks.” That level of specificity makes it easier to measure progress and notice when you are off track!


Evidence also suggests that writing down goals, creating action commitments and adding accountability meaningfully improves follow-through. In one study, participants who wrote their goals, listed action steps, shared them with a friend AND sent weekly progress updates achieved their goals at substantially higher rates than those who simply thought about their goals.


Putting it together: manifestation as filter, goals as roadmap

If you put these pieces together, a practical, evidence-informed model for the year ahead looks like this:

1. Clarify your intentions (manifestation as filter)

Start by asking: “What do I want my brain to treat as important this year?” That might be deep work, health, financial stability, creativity, relationships, or something else. Practices like visualisation, journalling about your future self and repeating key intentions can help keep these front-of-mind, shaping the “settings” of your selective attention system.

2. Translate intentions into specific goals 

For each high-level intention, define one to three concrete outcomes for the next 3-12 months. Make them as specific and measurable as possible and check that they fit your real constraints. For example: “Increase my consulting revenue by 20% by December” or “Complete a 10km run by July without stopping.”

3. Add implementation intentions and milestones

For each goal, create if-then plans that lock in when, where and how you will act. Research on implementation intentions shows that this step can strongly increase the likelihood you follow through. Pair this with milestones-monthly or quarterly check-ins where you review data, not just feelings, about your progress.

4. Use your “filter” in daily decisions

Your manifestation work gives you a lens for real-time choices: “Does this opportunity align with the intentions I set?” and “Is this decision moving me closer to or further from my stated goals?” Over time, repeatedly choosing in line with your intentions and plans reshapes both your results and your sense of identity.

In other words, manifestation is a way of consciously tuning the filter that guides what you pay attention to and care about; structured goal setting and planning are how you operationalise that filter into daily action over the year.


A practical template you can use

You can adapt this yearly process into something like:

- Choose 4 or so key intentions across key life pillars for the year (e.g., health, purpose, finances and relationships).  

- Spend time visualising and journalling about what life looks and feels like if those are truly your priorities, reinforcing them weekly to prime your attention.

- For each intention, set at least one SMART-style goal with a clear metric and timeframe.

- Write 2-3 implementation intentions per goal: “If it is [situation], then I will [action].”

- Schedule monthly or quarterly reviews to look at real data and adjust your plans.


Used together in this way, manifestation and goal setting are not rivals; they are two sides of a coherent change process: one shapes what stands out to you, the other shapes what you consistently do about it.

Happy 2026 lovely people and let us know how you go with your intention/goal setting!

Love Gracie and Anna x

SOURCES & FURTHER READING

Anna Grutzner
Previous

Reintroducing: Soluna Society
Next

Navigating the New Psychosocial Health Regulations: Why Nervous System Support Matters More Than Ever